Having said that, it's not impossible to make an adult book on dinosaurs that is engaging. For example, Donald Prothero's The Story of the Dinosaurs in 25 Discoveries overcame the problem by driving the book from the stories of the discoverers of the relevant fossils, while Benton's previous book Dinosaurs Rediscovered, while not quite at the same level, managed to do better than the average by focussing on new discoveries like skin pigmentation and feathers while dipping into some topics in detail and taking a charming, if occasionally over-whimsical, approach.
In some ways, this new title (fully 'Dinosaurs - new visions of a lost world') is very much more of the same to Dinosaurs Rediscovered, down to the book being rather heavier than is comfortable for the reader's wrists. Once again, it focuses on the newer discoveries - those pigments and feathers again, for example - and presenting the best picture we can of how we now think dinosaurs looked and behaved. In part you could see it as an updated versions of the already dated TV show 'Walking with Dinosaurs' in book form. It shares the strengths and weaknesses of that series. It does help bring some aspects of dinosaurs to life, but it sometimes sounds as if it's describing fact, rather than best current conjecture given the limited data we have.
In total, the book covers 15 species, most of which are relatively unfamiliar with the exception of archaeopteryx, the well-known proto-bird. There's no t-rex or velociraptor, which is distinctly refreshing. There are plenty of illustrations, both photographic and in coloured artworks, produced by 'palaeoartist' Bob Nicholls, which includes the remarkable looking tupandactylus (technically a pterosaur rather than a dinosaur) featured on the cover. This one is surely just waiting to star in its own animated movie.
The book is certainly quite interesting in a QI sense, but I struggled to keep engaged enough to bother too much after getting through three or four species. In the end, I'm more physicist than stamp collector in my attitude to science. This no doubt makes it my fault that I didn't get more out of this book - but other dinosaur titles have captured my attention more effectively. It is, however, a good addition to the collection of adults who delight in dinosaurs.
Hardback: ![]() |
Bookshop.org |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEh-cI2zgkD_3HrbTj9Rls-widBPcwhf4Rn0k9dRDTezu_jhVrvNgze4kvQVzaWczygZiO3TBLQ_mhx32PKlKzY4H3rsgzpDgLPC9biG_ipdrMNsCQpZg10W-xz9jD08_9j6FfXoIdpYmOQo/s400/buyuk.gif)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiMxzYlb2y4OAe2pxPU2M1IRe1TxJejcYqbPf2E30rPX2QzJ7zB6Qjeft8aJaXpElNANxsiwog_qwR-TcWwanFJfJ1AODVT2bj6HRoKFigv68OE30TscpDVDM71flOTjqTqQwZfG9WlCDaM/s400/buyus.gif)
Review by Brian Clegg
Comments
Post a Comment