Along the way, Lombrozo makes powerful use of case studies (stories) to make her points, though sometimes these backfire a little when she repeatedly comes back to the same case study rather than moving on. Along the way, we get some key points about explanation - that good explanations are much more satisfying than non-answers, that good explanations lead to further useful questions, stimulating our curiosity, and that explanations are not just about presenting facts, but are 'mental acts'. This is very much the key to the whole book. It seems more the driving factor of an article than a book-length thesis, but Lombrozo is able to make some interesting points along the way.
There are, however a few issues. There are plenty of references to academic papers and books, but some of these date back as far as the 60s, and there are plenty pre-2012. To do this with no mention of the replication crisis in psychology and other social sciences, citing such papers without any warning seems inappropriate these days. Although correlation gets a brief mention, there really isn't much emphasis given to the danger of 'explanations' that are based on correlation rather than causation. And there were some rather worrying errors.
We are told, for instance, that Lewis Carroll's real name was Charles Dobson. And we are told that James Clerk Maxwell was himself as uncertain of the fate of his discoveries as was Hertz - 'when asked what electricity was good for, [Maxwell] allegedly replied, "I do not know, but I'm pretty sure that Her Majesty's government will soon tax it."' I'm pretty sure that Maxwell would never have said 'I'm pretty sure' - the quote is usually given as 'I know not, but I wager one day your government will tax it.' But then, this isn't a quote from Maxwell: it was Michael Faraday, allegedly speaking either to Prime Minister Robert Peel or Chancellor William Gladstone. To get such a famous incident in the history of science wrong seems to suggest some issues with the content.
Overall, then, interesting ideas about explanation (even if it is subset of story), but for me it doesn't work brilliantly as a popular science book.
Review by Brian Clegg - See all our online articles or subscribe to a weekly email free here



Comments
Post a Comment