Skip to main content

Why We Ask Why - Tania Lombrozo ***

As Tania Lombrozo makes clear, we have been bombarded over the years with ideas of what makes humans special (if anything at all) - this new suggestion is that it is about eliciting explanations. Having made the case for story as our definitive behaviour in Brainjacking, I can't entirely agree with Lombrozo's assertion that explanation trumps story because 'many of our explanations take the form of stories, and often we seek stories when we want to answer why. So an even better characterisation might be this: humans are the primates who explain - distinctive amongst the world's flora and fauna in our drive to understand.' Given we are told that explanation is a subset of story (which does a lot more in its unique nature), this hardly seems a good explanation of why explanation is a better characterisation.

Along the way, Lombrozo makes powerful use of case studies (stories) to make her points, though sometimes these backfire a little when she repeatedly comes back to the same case study rather than moving on. Along the way, we get some key points about explanation - that good explanations are much more satisfying than non-answers, that good explanations lead to further useful questions, stimulating our curiosity, and that explanations are not just about presenting facts, but are 'mental acts'. This is very much the key to the whole book. It seems more the driving factor of an article than a book-length thesis, but Lombrozo is able to make some interesting points along the way.

There are, however a few issues. There are plenty of references to academic papers and books, but some of these date back as far as the 60s, and there are plenty pre-2012. To do this with no mention of the replication crisis in psychology and other social sciences, citing such papers without any warning seems inappropriate these days. Although correlation gets a brief mention, there really isn't much emphasis given to the danger of 'explanations' that are based on correlation rather than causation. And there were some rather worrying errors.

We are told, for instance, that Lewis Carroll's real name was Charles Dobson. And we are told that James Clerk Maxwell was himself as uncertain of the fate of his discoveries as was Hertz - 'when asked what electricity was good for, [Maxwell] allegedly replied, "I do not know, but I'm pretty sure that Her Majesty's government will soon tax it."' I'm pretty sure that Maxwell would never have said 'I'm pretty sure' - the quote is usually given as 'I know not, but I wager one day your government will tax it.' But then, this isn't a quote from Maxwell: it was Michael Faraday, allegedly speaking either to Prime Minister Robert Peel or Chancellor William Gladstone. To get such a famous incident in the history of science wrong seems to suggest some issues with the content.

Overall, then, interesting ideas about explanation (even if it is subset of story), but for me it doesn't work brilliantly as a popular science book.

Hardback:   
Kindle:  
Using these links earns us commission at no cost to you
These articles will always be free - but if you'd like to support my online work, consider buying a virtual coffee or taking out a membership:
Review by Brian Clegg - See all our online articles or subscribe to a weekly email free here

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Six Maths Essentials - Terence Tao *****

This is a book in the 'compact collection of science/maths essays' category beloved of publishers because they can charge hardback prices for fewer than 80 pages of text - but don't let that put you off, because it's excellent. Terence Tao introduces six areas of mathematics: numbers, algebra, geometry, probability, analysis and dynamics. Each of these is descriptive rather than practical (there are only a couple of school-level equations in sight), done in a way that gets to the heart of 'what's the point of this subject' with precision and a good level of storytelling. It's a shame in a way that analysis and dynamics form the final third of the book (apart from a short epilogue), because they don't work as well as the other sections. For the first four, practically everyone will have a vague idea of what they are and what they do - but Tao is then able to open our eyes to their wonders and power. Because Tao has to stay away from any detail of what...

Bradley Efron - Five Way Interview

Bradley Efron is Max Stein Professor emeritus of Statistics and of Biomedical Data Science at Stanford University. He is the inventor of the bootstrap method for assessing statistical accuracy and has published extensively on the theory and practice of data analysis. He has served as president of the American Statistical Association and the Institute of Mathematical Statistics.  A MacArthur fellow, he is a member of the National Academy of Sciences and received the National Medal of Science in 2005. His remarkable contributions to his field were recognized again with the 2018 International Prize in Statistics, which noted his influence on 'statistical thinking in every way, including new pathways in how we communicate and teach statistics to all.' His latest book is To Think Like a Statistician . Why mathematics?   Abstract mathematics and I had an amicable divorce following my Caltech graduation. (I really wasn’t very good at it.) Statistics is a branch of applied mathematics...

Time Now - Colin Gillespie ***

A quote on the back cover of this book describes it as monumental - it certainly feels big enough to use as part of a structure with 664 pages plus a further 112 pages of end notes. Colin Gillespie's aim is to 'bring together centuries of ancient thought and modern insights to unearth what is real and what is not'. That certainly sounds like it would need a lot of pages, if it is to be achieved at all. A starting point is to establish what 'real' means. Gillespie gives us the guidance that 'to accept something as truly real, it must be an accurately described objective aspect of the universe.' That may seem obvious, but as he points out 'little in philosophy or physics even aims to pass this test.' Gillespie builds a new conception of physics based entirely on space. As he puts it 'space isn't something; it is literally everything.' In this worldview, the universe began with a single 'space quantum' - a Planck-sized six-dimensiona...