A starting point is to establish what 'real' means. Gillespie gives us the guidance that 'to accept something as truly real, it must be an accurately described objective aspect of the universe.' That may seem obvious, but as he points out 'little in philosophy or physics even aims to pass this test.'
Gillespie builds a new conception of physics based entirely on space. As he puts it 'space isn't something; it is literally everything.' In this worldview, the universe began with a single 'space quantum' - a Planck-sized six-dimensional Calabi-Yu manifold which 'replicated stepwise in successive iterations' by tunnelling into two, then four and so on quanta. This universe only has three dimensions, where its stepwise iteration gives it sequence, 'leading to a universal kind of time.' Here, space and the quantum are the same thing. In getting your mind around this its hard not to see these iterations requiring time as something separate measuring the duration of the iterations, but the idea is it is unnecessary.
I love what Gillespie is attempting to do here, but for me there were two big problems with the way he does it. One is the book is just way too long. With an aim to get to the core of reality, we would do a lot better with a focused title rather than one that gives so much context and detail. Everything is approached indirectly: rather than giving it us straight, Gillespie dances around the topic time after time (ironically if time doesn't exist). Secondly, the book is way too quote-heavy. Quotes from other sources are useful seasoning to books, but the eye tends to bounce off them if there are too many. Practically every page has multiple quotes and this makes the whole thing difficult to read nor is it possible to get any sense of a flowing narrative.
I certainly could give this book five stars for what it attempts to do, but have to rein that back because the way it's approached makes it near-impossible to clearly get to the message. There's way too much coming close to the point without making it. There may be something to Colin Gillespie's big idea - but for me, at least, this is not the way to put it across to a reader... and I never really discovered a better answer than 42.
Review by Brian Clegg - See all our online articles or subscribe to a weekly email free here



Comments
Post a Comment